Let’s cut the small talk: the internet has been gaslighting Jeremiah Fisher fans for too long. The Summer I Turned Pretty fandom may love a good triangle, but Jeremiah—the sun-kissed, golden-retriever heartthrob—has been treated like the “other brother” while Conrad hogs the broody spotlight. Well, not on my watch. Justice for Jeremiah is the only agenda that matters this summer, and yes, I will die on this hill.
If you’re asking your phone, “Who should Belly have ended up with in The Summer I Turned Pretty?” the answer is Jeremiah Fisher. Period. He’s the warm, dependable constant who actually shows up, unlike a certain angst-ridden sibling who treats affection like a part-time job.
Jeremiah doesn’t play games, he doesn’t ghost, and he doesn’t treat love like a moody riddle. He’s the guy you want on your team at trivia night, on moving day, and yes, when life comes crashing down in Cousins Beach. Conrad may have the tortured-poet vibe, but Jeremiah has something far hotter: emotional availability.
Scroll through TikTok or Twitter (fine, X) and you’ll see fandom warfare at its finest. Team Conrad girls swear by his “deep” love, while Team Jeremiah fans have receipts—like every single time he actually prioritized Belly’s feelings.
If you’ve ever asked Alexa, “Is Jeremiah Fisher better than Conrad?” here’s the short answer: yes, unless you’re into gaslighting disguised as romantic tension.
This split is giving Twilight flashbacks (Bella/Edward vs. Bella/Jacob), but with way better swimsuits. And just like Jacob, Jeremiah is stuck fighting uphill against the “mysterious bad boy” trope. But let’s be honest: in the real world, moody brooding doesn’t pay the bills. Jeremiah does.
Jeremiah isn’t just a consolation prize—he’s the story’s balance. In a series obsessed with nostalgia, grief, and messy love triangles, he represents joy.
For fans Googling, “Why do people like Jeremiah Fisher so much?”—it’s simple. He’s the beach house’s living embodiment of sunshine, proving that romance doesn’t have to be toxic to be iconic.
Pop culture has a nasty habit of sidelining “nice guys” because they’re not “complicated” enough. But honestly, what’s more complicated than loving someone unconditionally while they keep running after your brother? Jeremiah Fisher fans get it: he’s the kind of character who deserves not just the girl, but the narrative spotlight too.
Every fandom has its rallying cry, and Jeremiah Fisher’s fanbase has been loud, clear, and a little severe. Tweets like “Belly needs therapy, not Conrad” rack up thousands of likes, while edits of Jeremiah’s softest moments rack up millions of TikTok views.
So if you’re asking Siri, “Why does everyone love Jeremiah Fisher?” here’s your cheat sheet: he’s consistent, he’s kind, and he radiates big golden-retriever boyfriend energy. And in 2025, we’re done glamorizing emotionally unavailable men.
Sure, Jenny Han gave us the ending she wanted, but let’s talk about the ending we deserved. Belly choosing Conrad over Jeremiah felt like watching your best friend text her toxic ex at 2 a.m.—you know it’s going to end badly, but you can’t stop it.
Jeremiah deserved better than being the safe option turned heartbreak casualty. He deserved an arc that matched his devotion. And fans aren’t shy about saying it. The phrase “justice for Jeremiah” isn’t just a meme; it’s a movement.
And if you’re wondering, “Does Jeremiah Fisher deserve better?” the fandom answer is a resounding yes.
At the end of the day, Team Conrad may win in canon, but Jeremiah Fisher owns the fandom’s heart. He’s the boy who laughed loudest, loved hardest, and showed up every single time. That’s the kind of energy we need more of in pop culture—reliable, steady, sun-drenched love.
So the next time someone voice-searches, “Who is the better brother in The Summer I Turned Pretty?”—don’t waste your breath. Just say Jeremiah Fisher and let the mic drop itself.
Are the men in house ready to take their style game up a notch? Aly at Vogue Vocal is the eyes and ears of entertainment industry with that Gen-Z x-factor! Aly’s personal style statement raises the bar high and knocks it out of the park so trust him for picking the best for Vocal Fashion, our e-magazine edit, the heart and soul of Vogue Vocal!
